Elderly Jewish couple suing American Airlines after they were ‘kicked off flight over prayer scarf’

An aged Jewish couple says they were kicked off an American Airlines flight and left stranded in Miami forward of a hurricane after they refused to place their Tallit prayer scarf on the ground beneath their seat, which might violate their faith.  

Roberto and Elena Birman were flying from Miami to Newark, New Jersey in August when they were ‘subjected to unlawful and discriminatory conduct’ by a flight attendant, in line with a lawsuit filed on November 29.

The unnamed stewardess was checking the overhead compartments when she got here throughout Roberto’s Tallit bag, which contained a scarf worn by Orthodox Jewish males throughout prayer. 

The attendant put it on his lap and instructed him to stuff it beneath his seat. When the Brooklyn couple refused, the attendant and pilot allegedly kicked them off the aircraft.

American Airlines instructed DailyMail.com that they are ‘reviewing the small print of the lawsuit.’

Orthodox Jewish couple Roberto and Elena Birman of Brooklyn, New York say they were kicked off a flight in August for refusing to place their Tallit bag beneath their seat

The clear 8.5-in-by-8.5-in bag, above, contained a prayer scarf and and ebook

The swimsuit, filed within the Eastern District of New York, particulars how the couple boarded the aircraft and even supplied to test of their baggage when nobody else volunteered.

‘However, because the previous saying goes, no good deed goes unpunished.’ the lawsuit states.

The Birmans are searching for unspecified damages and lawyer’s charges.

They were sitting in aisle seats throughout from one another and carried solely a briefcase, a handbag and the 8.5-inch-by 8.5-inch clear Tallit bag, which contained a scarf and prayer ebook. 

After recognizing it within the overhead bin, the flight attendant requested, ‘Whose is that this?’ the Birmans instructed the New York Post.

The attendant requested him to place it on the bottom.

‘It’s a spiritual merchandise, it can’t go beneath the seat,’ Roberto, 76, stated. 

He eliminated his baseball cap to point out the kippah masking his head, explaining that it’s ‘towards his faith to put the sacred Tallit bag on the ground,’ in line with the lawsuit.

‘It doesn’t matter,’ the attendant allegedly responded. 

‘She was screaming at me and pointing her finger,’ Roberto instructed the Post.

The flight attendant and pilot then requested Roberto and his spouse to go away the aircraft.

‘At that time the Birmans were confused, deeply humiliated, disrespected, lost, perplexed, and at an entire loss. Mr. and Mrs. Birman were being discriminated towards due to their race, faith and nationality and earlier than a planeload of different passengers,’ the lawsuit says.

The couple has been married for 52 years and moved to the US in 1985 from Argentina, the place they say they skilled anti-Semitism.  

‘I couldn’t imagine this was occurring to me in America,” Roberto stated. ‘We use these things each single day to wish.’

Elana, 71, stated, ‘Nobody stated a phrase. Nobody defended us. It was embarrassing.’

Rabbi Mitchell Rocklin, president of the Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty, instructed the Post that inserting the Tallit on the bottom is ‘thought of disgraceful.’

‘It can be like taking a Bible or a Koran and dumping it on the ground.’

Elena in contrast the flight attendant’s request with asking a Christian to ‘throw a cross on the ground.’

The couple was aboard an American Airlines flight from Miami to Newark, New Jersey. American Airlines says it is ‘reviewing the small print of the lawsuit’

The couple says American Airlines did not assist them discover a place to remain that night time, and they weren’t capable of safe a flight again dwelling till the subsequent day, August 13, although Tropical Storm Fred was barreling towards the state.  

The storm landed on the Florida Panhandle on August 16, inflicting tens of 1000’s of energy outages, in line with CNN.

The lawsuit says the Birmans ‘were ejected from the flight based mostly on the prejudices and full lack of sensitivity of airline workers and brokers for causes wholly unrelated to safety.

‘Your flight attendant and pilot’s conduct was as offensive because it was illogical.’

The couple says they were left with out Roberto’s diabetes drugs, which was within the luggage they agreed to test in. 

A crew member allegedly shouted, ‘Close the gate,’ as they disembarked.  

‘What are we, criminals?’ Elena thought, including that her husband ‘was devastated.’

‘It was out of proportion’ to what occurred, Roberto stated, including that the flight attendant ‘made me so nervous. I used to be shaking.’

American Airlines spokesman Matt Miller stated: ‘The security and luxury of our clients are our highest priorities and we’re dedicated to offering a constructive, welcoming expertise for everybody who travels with us.’

Related Posts